Like moores law, which states that the number of transistors on a chip will double every 18 to 20 months, metcalfes law is a rough empirical description, not an immutable physical law. Metcalfes law revisited dmitri nosovicki abstractrudimentary mathematical analysis of simple network models suggests bandwidthindependent saturation ofnetwork growth dynamics, as well as hints at linear decrease in information density of the data. The law states that the value of a network is proportional to the square of the number of its users see gilder, 1993. Coined by robert metcalfe, the inventor of ethernet, metcalfes law states that the value of a network grows by the square of the size of the network. Metcalfes law states that the value of a communications network is proportional to the. The paper discusses the fundamental flaw of metcalfe s law and describes how zipf s law can be used as basis to justify the n logn ruleofthumb valuation of a general communications network of. Gilder s law, metcalfes law, moores law, shannons law, 1. Cryptocurrencies, metcalfes law and lppl models ional.
A dated but still valid article by george gilder describes metcalfes law and legacy. A phone network is a perfect example to illustrate metcalfes law. Metcalfes law was validated in various contexts, by using social network data. The law states that a networks value increases with the size of the network. The law was named in 1993 by george gilder, publisher of the influential gilder technology report. With social networks that equation is driven to being able to include anybody within the entire network into your subgroup. Will revolutionize our world, the free press, 2000. The ease of use and usefulness of craigs list makes it an irresistible network to join thanks to metcalfes law as it provides tremendous value for linking up buyers and sellers and does this for free thanks to moores law. George gilder, metcalfes law and legacy, forbes asap, sept. Dec 15, 2018 in 1994, george gilder credited metcalfes law as one of the foundations of his law. Those two, character e and symbol are in some cases an interface between. A refutation of metcalfes law and a better estimate for the value of. It has drawn a lot of criticism in explaining web 2.
Introduction today, every term in the computer and telecommunication field has the prefix e, obviously, to refer to the electronics era. It was dubbed metcalfes law by george gilder 8 in the. Metcalfes law the value of a network is proportional to the square of the number of nodes 2 users 1 connection 5 users 10 connections many users exponential benefit nn12. He actually came up with a theorem based on george gilder, which is the value of a network is the square of the number of users. Metcalfes law assumes that the value of each node n is of equal benefit. Metcalfes law and operational, analytical and collaborative crmusing online business communities for cocreation. It is suggested that the managerial tasks and information and communication. First formulated in this form by george gilder in 1993, and attributed to robert. Mar 12, 2010 metcalfes law was defined when the main goal was being able to access other nodes, for general communications, either an email or a transaction. Tying metcalfe and moores law together on digital marketing. Metcalfes law characterizes many of the network effects of communication technologies and networks such as the internet, social networking, and the world wide web. Mar, 2015 in 1980s, robert metcalfe, the inventor of ethernet, proposed a formulation of network value in terms of the network size the number of nodes of the network, which was later named as metcalfes law.
Buyerweb provides one of many possible examples of a service taking advantage of metcalfes law. A single phone really just being an end point in a network called a node. A refutation of metcalfes law and a better estimate for the value of networks and network interconnections andrewodlyzko1 andbenjamintilly2 1 digital technology center, university of minnesota 499 walter library, 117 pleasant st. It is often cited in discussions about the value of the internet. Metcalfes law states the value of a telecommunications network is proportional to the square of the number of users of the system n2. For metcalfes views, see metcalfe, metcalfes law, supra note 7, at 53 ok, metcalfes law might overestimate the value of a network for a very large n. George gilder dubbed metcalfes observation a law in his metcalfes law and legacy, an article that was published in the september 1993. The industry is at it againtrying to figure out what to make of metcalfes law. Metcalfes law gilder, 1993 which defines the network value as proportional to the square of its size. However, gilder s article talks about machines and not users.
Facebook values itself based on metcalfes law, but the. Gilders law, metcalfes law, moores law, shannons law. The main thrust of the argument is that the value of a network grows onlogn as opposed to on 2. Thus, the ratio of value to cost of adding one more network user grows disproportionately as the network grows larger. Metcalfes law was widely accepted and used to explain internet. Rather, they are proposals of separate laws that use the same mathematical relationship squaring.
Both of these value propositions are directly linked back to metcalfe and moore. Jan 16, 2020 common misunderstandings about metcalfes law and the network effect. The paper discusses the fundamental flaw of metcalfes law and describes how zipfs law can be used as basis to justify the n logn ruleofthumb valuation of a general communications network of. Moores law, gilder s law, metcalfes law, and the law of disruption. Given that the internet as we know it today was not around when the law was formulated, it spoke more to the value of devices in general. I removed the entire section applications of metcalfes law because none of the examples are applications of the law. Metcalfes law is related to the fact that the number of. Some other laws have been proposed, including sarnoffs law v. For example, if the network has 5 machines, its value would be 25 5225, but if another network had. Metcalfes law states that a networks value is proportional to the square of the number of users. However, the companys everexpanding motif crashed when the targeted group of customers laid off 40 percent of their workers and banned discretionary expenditures.
Metcalfe specifically theorized about the value of telecommunication networks. Metcalfes law has been influential and an embodiment of the network effect concept. New developments seem to confirm that bandwidth availability will continue to expand at a rate that supports gilder s law. Metcalfes law states the effect of a telecommunications network is proportional to the square of the number of connected users of the system n2. Also called law of telecosm, it was proposed by robert c. The basic point of metcalfes law is that the value of networks exhibits superlinear growth. Hes equally proud of metcalfes law, so named by friend george gilder. The value, imo, is more in the concept than in the application. Journal of targeting, measurement and analysis for marketing, mar 2012. Metcalfes and gilder s law 10 detailed calculation of metcalfes law if you have n items could be computers, people, or other interacting things. What are the applications and limitations of metcalfes. I removed the entire section applications of metcalfe s law because none of the examples are applications of the law. The law states that the value v of a network is proportional to the square of the size n of the network, i. The law states that a network s value increases with the size of the network.
Metcalfes law and herding behaviour in the cryptocurrencies. Metcalfes law is a very good fit for bitcoins price. Scaling social networks metcalfe, moore, and craigs list. Unfortunately, the authors onlogn suggeston is no more accurate or insightful than the original proposal. It took off after he convinced xerox, minicomputer maker digital equipment corp pcs were launched only in 1981, and chipmaker intel to adopt the ethernet as a public standard. Metcalfes law has been influential and an embodiment of the network. Metcalfes and gilder s law 15 the network in the beginning there was the. Like moores law, it feeds on an array of related advances.
Continue reading about metcalfes law a presentation at the infonortics web site is our source for the original statement. Hence it observes a positive feedback between the value of a network and the number of people using and contributing to. Gilder proclaimed the laws importance in the development of. Coined by robert metcalfe, the inventor of ethernet, metcalfe s law states that the value of a network grows by the square of the size of the network. A refutation of metcalfes law and a better estimate for. In 1980s, robert metcalfe, the inventor of ethernet, proposed a formulation of network value in terms of the network size the number of nodes of the network, which was later named as metcalfes law.
Like moores law, the law of the telecosm will reshape the entire world of information technology. Some scholars went so far as to state metcalfes law is wrong and dangerous. A user equipped to communicate with 50 million other users might not have all that much to talk about with each of them. Metcalfes law states that the value of a telecommunications network is proportional to the square of the number of connected users of the system n2. For instance, its obvious that if youre the only person with a telephone then that network would have no value, when one additional person gets a phone the network has achieved a tiny bit of value, and if virtually everyone has a phone. Metcalfe s law characterizes many of the network effects of communication technologies and networks such as the internet, social networking, and the world wide web. Metcalfes law was conceived by george gilder but is attributed to robert metcalfe, coinventor of ethernet 1980. This is the well famous metcalfes law, that somehow caused the rapid growth of. Metcalfes law was widely accepted and used to explain internet boom. A refutation of metcalfes law and a better estimate for the.
Searching for the intermedia agendasetting effects in the presi. The advancement of online longrange informal communication made it conceivable to confirm that a network pursues metcalfes law in light of the fact that facebook was tried with the law and it. If this is not the case, for example because the one fax machines serves 50 workers in a company, the second fax machine serves half of that, the third one third, and so on, then the relative value of an additional connection decreases. Pdf how did metcalfes law affected satellite systems. This time its ieee spectrum with a controversially titled metcalfes law is wrong. Metcalfes law was defined when the main goal was being able to access other nodes, for general communications, either an email or a transaction. The maxim, conceived to convince the world to adopt his ethernet standard, reads thus. Total value of a network to its users grows as the square of the total number of its users. This annual doubling in size is commonly ascribed to metcalfes law4 by the computer community. Wilson distinguished professor of higher education, emerging technologies, and. We now know that both metcalfes and moores laws are exponential in nature which, to drastically simplify, means they increase. It defines the direction of technological advance, the vectors of growth, the sweet spots for finance.
Most of the other companies also have some of their success due to deployment of it technologies. An evolutionary stage model of cyberspace is proposed based on the four key fundamental driving forces. Lets take a brief second to understand how these two laws overlap in a realworld example to better understand the implications for the case of traditional print media. Federal communications commission reed hundt said that this law gives the most understanding to the workings of the internet. Metcalfes law states that the value of a telecommunications network is proportional to the square of the number of nodes or users on the system. This paper connects transaction cost theory tct with metcalfes law. It not only proves that they are consistent but also makes economical sense of the law by introducing the second critical mass in to metcalfes law. Metcalfes law is attributed to robert metcalfe, a former researcher at the famous xerox palo alto research center who coinvented ethernet. The power of the web is enhanced through the network effect produced as resources link to each other with the value determined by metcalfe s law. May 28, 2019 metcalfes law was conceived by george gilder but is attributed to robert metcalfe, coinventor of ethernet 1980. The power of the web is enhanced through the network effect produced as resources link to each other with the value determined by. Pdf tencent and facebook data validate metcalfes law. George gilder dubbed metcalfes observation a law in his metcalfes law and legacy, an article that was published in the september 1993 issue of forbes asap. Jul 26, 2006 the credit for the users formulation goes to george gilder who wrote about metcalfes law in forbes asap on september, 1993.
1268 434 89 1621 87 1042 637 1685 1242 130 583 98 487 1658 1150 867 46 1631 1691 1181 548 822 674 919 1401 574 1441 704 1380 63 802